| Platinum | Hermanos Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Matt's Rancho Martinez |
| Silver | Torchys Tacos |
| Bronze | Salsa Texmex |
| Top Pick | Anasofia's Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Chepa's Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | El Grande Burrito |
| Top Pick | Gloria's Latin Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Mi Cocina |
| Top Pick | Neon Cactus |