| Platinum | Spazo Restaurant & Bar |
| Gold | TwoRows Classic Grill |
| Silver | Labi's |
| Bronze | 5th Street Pizza |
| Top Pick | Chicago Pizza Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Crazy Tomato Pizza Pasta |
| Top Pick | Grimaldi's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Italian Villa Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Joe's Italian Bistro |
| Top Pick | New York Pizza & Pints |